Clippind Desk: Movie Reviews
The City of God
Review by Luke McManus. Published by Entertainment Online, on 30 /12/ 2002



"Set on the mean streets of a Rio de Janeiro slum (in the "Cidade de Deus" housing project), this film follows two boys who grow up down differing paths (stretched across over 15 years, from the late 1960s to the early 1980s). One, Buscape (Rodrigues), becomes a photographer, the other becomes a drug dealer. The film follows their paths through a series of short stories, as we learn about the violent, often short lives of those wrapped up in the dangerous world of drugs and crime on Brazil's cruelest area". (Check more movie reviews at movies.yahoo.com)

The 'City of God' is directed by Fernando Meirelles (see interview). Starring Matheus Nachtergaele, Seu Jorge, Alexandre Rodrigues, Leandro Firmino da Hora, Philippe Haagensen, Johnathan Haagensen, Douglas Silva, Roberta Rodriguez Silvia.

"(...) In the 1960s, faced with urban decay and large-scale slums, city planners decide to create a brand-new suburb, giving the poor access to public housing. It is built without any amenities and without any consideration for the people who will live there.

Before long the estate is decaying and crime-ridden. Faced with unemployment or badly-paid menial work, most of its young people opt for drugs and gunplay. 'City Of God' might be set in the outskirts of Rio, but its situation has universal echoes.

The film is an assured meditation on the inevitability of violence in a ghetto where people are almost entirely without hope. Fortunately the killings, and their underlying social discontent, are lightened with dark humour and engaging performances.

The acting is uniformly authentic, understandably, as the child actors were recruited from the favela streets in which the film is set, avoiding the saccharin gloss of stage school.

Different actors play the main characters, as children and as young adults. Douglas Silva is arresting as the child villain Little Dice, whose cold-eyed acceptance of murder as a tool of self-progression is utterly
convincing. Leandro Firmino de Hora also excels in the same character's adult role, with a performance that is spine-chillingly real in its lust for power and disregard for human life.

Many key moments are familiar, but none the less powerful for it - the narrator is unjustly sacked from his dead-end job, and then sees a drug lord of his own age showing off his new motorcycle. The problems
of young love, staying on the straight and narrow and eventually escaping the ghetto are amplified by the ultimate price paid by so many of the characters.

'City of God' tells its episodic story with the help of strong performances, but the film also excels in technical areas. Cesar Charlone's grainy, sun-drenched camerawork is reminiscent of 'Traffic', while Daniel Rezende's stunning, hyper-kinetic editing only occasionally distracts from the film's flow.

Most of all, the film is heartfelt and full of passion, without ever descending into sentimentality. It might be early days, but 'City Of God' is already a contender for the best film of 2003 and Fernando Meirelles is a name that you will definitely hear again."



COPYRIGHT © 2003-1997 BRZ GROUP
Send your opinion about this article to: editor@brazilianist.com
416-826-1455 - Toronto, Canada
www.brazilianist.com